American Financial Group Inc. (AFGB) intrinsic value & 10-year financials

American Financial Group Inc. (AFGB) has a Graham intrinsic value of $136.53 per share. Over the last 10 fiscal years revenue grew 2.6% a year to $8.2B, with an average return on invested capital of 16.6%.

Graham intrinsic value
$136.53
Revenue (FY2025)
$8.2B
Revenue growth (10-yr CAGR)
2.6%
ROIC (10-yr avg)
16.6%
Free cash flow (FY2025)
—

AFGB 10-year financial history

Fiscal year Revenue Net income EPS (diluted) Free cash flow Operating margin ROIC
FY2025 $8.2B $842.0M $10.08 — 13.1% 17.8%
FY2024 $8.3B $887.0M $10.57 — 13.5% 19.6%
FY2023 $7.8B $852.0M $10.05 — 13.7% 18.6%
FY2022 $7.0B $898.0M $10.53 — 16.0% 18.9%
FY2021 $6.6B $2.0B $23.30 — 20.4% 22.0%
FY2020 $7.9B $732.0M $8.20 — 10.7% 12.7%
FY2019 $8.2B $897.0M $9.85 — 13.5% 17.2%
FY2018 $7.2B $530.0M $5.85 — 8.9% 11.5%
FY2017 $6.9B $475.0M $5.28 — 10.5% 11.4%
FY2016 $6.5B $649.0M $7.33 — 12.1% 16.3%

Source: annual 10-K filings on SEC EDGAR. Figures in USD.

Executive summary

AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC has demonstrated mature, steady growth, with revenue compounding at 2.6% annually over the past decade.

AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC has earned high returns on invested capital, averaging 16.6% ROIC over the available history. High ROIC is consistent with a durable franchise, but it is not by itself proof of an economic moat.

Over the decade, AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC shows that the company has leveraged its balance sheet to sustain operations.

Benjamin Graham lens

Under Benjamin Graham's formula using SEC EDGAR fundamentals, AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC is modeled at 3.6% normalized earnings growth with a 5.1% bond-yield adjustment. The resulting Graham intrinsic value estimate is $136.53 per share.

AFGB stock: frequently asked questions

What is the intrinsic value of American Financial Group Inc. (AFGB) stock?

Using Benjamin Graham's revised formula, V = EPS × (8.5 + 2g) × 4.4 / Y, with reported diluted earnings per share, a 3.6% normalized growth rate (capped at 15%) and a 5.1% AAA corporate bond yield, AFGB's intrinsic value is about $136.53 per share.

How fast has American Financial Group Inc. grown?

Revenue went from $6.5B in fiscal 2016 to $8.2B in fiscal 2025, a compound annual growth rate of 2.6%. Net income was $842.0M in fiscal 2025.

What is AFGB's return on invested capital?

Average ROIC over the last 10 fiscal years was 16.6%, and average return on equity was 17.2%. Sustained ROIC above about 15% usually points to a durable competitive advantage.

Where does this AFGB data come from?

From American Financial Group Inc.'s annual 10-K filings on SEC EDGAR, most recently filed Aug 6, 2026. Prices are end-of-day snapshots; valuations are formula outputs, not investment advice.

Similar fire, marine & casualty insurance stocks