Ategrity Specialty Insurance Co. Holdings (ASIC) intrinsic value & 10-year financials

Ategrity Specialty Insurance Co. Holdings (ASIC) has a Graham intrinsic value of $52.48 per share. At $27.25 on Oct 17, 2026, the stock trades 48% below that value. Over the last 3 fiscal years revenue grew 23.4% a year to $424.3M, with an average return on invested capital of 13.8%.

Graham intrinsic value
$52.48
Share price (Oct 17, 2026)
$27.25
Price vs Graham value
48% below
Market cap
$1.3B
Revenue (FY2025)
$424.3M
Revenue growth (3-yr CAGR)
23.4%
ROIC (10-yr avg)
13.8%
Free cash flow (FY2025)
$140.7M

ASIC 10-year financial history

Fiscal year Revenue Net income EPS (diluted) Free cash flow Operating margin ROIC
FY2025 $424.3M $74.0M $1.58 $140.7M — 14.6%
FY2024 $343.8M $47.1M $1.28 $125.4M — 13.1%
FY2023 — — — — — —

Source: annual 10-K filings on SEC EDGAR. Figures in USD.

Executive summary

Ategrity Specialty Insurance Co Holdings revenue growth over the past decade is N/A; insufficient history prevents a reliable 10-year CAGR calculation.

Ategrity Specialty Insurance Co Holdings returns on capital have been average, hovering around 13.8% ROIC over the decade.

Ategrity Specialty Insurance Co Holdings capital allocation metrics are N/A for the decade; share count and net debt history are incomplete.

Benjamin Graham lens

Under Benjamin Graham's formula using SEC EDGAR fundamentals, Ategrity Specialty Insurance Co Holdings is modeled at 15.0% normalized earnings growth with a 5.1% bond-yield adjustment. The resulting Graham intrinsic value estimate is $52.48 per share.

ASIC stock: frequently asked questions

What is the intrinsic value of Ategrity Specialty Insurance Co. Holdings (ASIC) stock?

Using Benjamin Graham's revised formula, V = EPS × (8.5 + 2g) × 4.4 / Y, with reported diluted earnings per share, a 15.0% normalized growth rate (capped at 15%) and a 5.1% AAA corporate bond yield, ASIC's intrinsic value is about $52.48 per share.

Is ASIC stock undervalued?

At $27.25 (close on Oct 17, 2026), ASIC trades 48% below its Graham value of $52.48. On Graham's terms that leaves a margin of safety. A formula is a starting point for research, not a recommendation.

Does Ategrity Specialty Insurance Co. Holdings generate free cash flow?

Ategrity Specialty Insurance Co. Holdings generated $140.7M of free cash flow (operating cash flow minus capital expenditures) in fiscal 2025. Free cash flow was positive in 2 of the last 2 reported years.

What is ASIC's return on invested capital?

Average ROIC over the last 3 fiscal years was 13.8%, and average return on equity was 13.8%. Sustained ROIC above about 15% usually points to a durable competitive advantage.

Where does this ASIC data come from?

From Ategrity Specialty Insurance Co. Holdings's annual 10-K filings on SEC EDGAR, most recently filed May 7, 2026. Prices are end-of-day snapshots; valuations are formula outputs, not investment advice.

Similar fire, marine & casualty insurance stocks